Mafia Round 4 - Six Million Forms of Communication - Page 3

Bube · 06-17-2009, 02:25 PM

All right, here's my "big" thing.

Fyacin told me, Germy and jeepnut that he was the vigilante. And got killed. Make of that what you will. I don't know if he had told anybody else. Or if it was a lucky guess by the mafia.

But seeing how everybody voted for Combine and BaB (I didn't, I know, but I was manipulated by him, unfortunately), I'm not really sure.

I'm quite suspicious of BlueFire, and I !vote BLuefire.

Teuthida · 06-17-2009, 07:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bube

Fyacin told me, Germy and jeepnut that he was the vigilante. And got killed. Make of that what you will. I don't know if he had told anybody else. Or if it was a lucky guess by the mafia.

When did Fyacin tell you guys?

I'm wary of Germy. I had him pegged as a goodie but after BAB's hint at the voting confusion and that he said it was easy to find out who the vigilante was. Germy's first post in this thread is oozing with generic goodguy patonthebackness. I try not to let the tone of posts make me jump to conclusions but that one just seemed off to me from how some baddies posted in past mafia games...well, Dylflon's too. Again don't want vote based on tone of post.

Bube · 06-17-2009, 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Teuthida

When did Fyacin tell you guys?

I'm wary of Germy. I had him pegged as a goodie but after BAB's hint at the voting confusion and that he said it was easy to find out who the vigilante was. Germy's first post in this thread is oozing with generic goodguy patonthebackness. I try not to let the tone of posts make me jump to conclusions but that one just seemed off to me from how some

He told us right at the beginning of the last round. And yes, Germy's first post got me thinking as well, but I agree with you. And I usually wait a bit before I come to a conclusion..

jeepnut · 06-17-2009, 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Teuthida

When did Fyacin tell you guys?

I'm wary of Germy. I had him pegged as a goodie but after BAB's hint at the voting confusion and that he said it was easy to find out who the vigilante was. Germy's first post in this thread is oozing with generic goodguy patonthebackness. I try not to let the tone of posts make me jump to conclusions but that one just seemed off to me from how some baddies posted in past mafia games...well, Dylflon's too. Again don't want vote based on tone of post.

Fyacin told us when I contacted everyone who voted for Combine in round 2. I contacted all of them together in a mass PM in order to form an alliance against BaB. Fyacin replied to all in the PM informing us that he was the vigilante.

Vampyr · 06-17-2009, 10:19 PM

We have the same people doing the same throw away vote thing again.

Gah.

I'm not so sure about mariolover anymore, but I don't have any better ideas.

I still suspect nighthawk and swan too, for voting for jeepnut last time.

Vampyr · 06-17-2009, 02:28 PM

!retract Nighthawk

!vote tornadothrasher

Okay, so...we have a situations where everyone who voted for Jeepnut (except swan so far) is like "lol BaB tricked me".

I'm halfway to believing this, since he tried the same thing with me.

I'm starting to get the feeling that 1 or 2 of the remaining mafia haven't been playing.

thatmariolover · 06-17-2009, 02:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vampyr

!retract Nighthawk

!vote tornadothrasher

Okay, so...we have a situations where everyone who voted for Jeepnut (except swan so far) is like "lol BaB tricked me".

I'm halfway to believing this, since he tried the same thing with me.

I'm starting to get the feeling that 1 or 2 of the remaining mafia haven't been playing.

I don't really know what to say. I wanted to trust somebody right away, BaB was a bad choice but he was fairly central in the alliance last game so I decided to start with him.

Now, the things BaB wanted me to believe make me suspicious. He was very protective of Dylflon and Vampyr. It was a bit foolish for him to say things like in the event that he was offed. I think the mafia decided since BaB looked so suspicious they were going to off him in the votes. Thus they make two of their own look innocent. After all, they voted for BaB.

That's why I'm holding to my vote for Dylfon. I firmly believe that he and Vampyr are the last two Mafia.

Vampyr · 06-17-2009, 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thatmariolover

I don't really know what to say. I wanted to trust somebody right away, BaB was a bad choice but he was fairly central in the alliance last game so I decided to start with him.

Now, the things BaB wanted me to believe make me suspicious. He was very protective of Dylflon and Vampyr. It was a bit foolish for him to say things like in the event that he was offed. I think the mafia decided since BaB looked so suspicious they were going to off him in the votes. Thus they make two of their own look innocent. After all, they voted for BaB.

That's why I'm holding to my vote for Dylfon. I firmly believe that he and Vampyr are the last two Mafia.

...

That has got to be the bizarre theory ever.

!retract Tornadothrasher

!vote thatmariolover

I should have just stuck with my original theory to begin with.

thatmariolover · 06-17-2009, 02:51 PM

Is it bizarre? Dylflon even posted at the end of the thread last time that he expected you to change your vote. Which you both conveniently did near the end of the voting cycle.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dylflon

I'm actually expecting Vampyr to change his vote back to BaB. If he can react in time.

http://www.gametavern.net/forums/sho...0&postcount=95

thatmariolover · 06-17-2009, 03:10 PM

No, because it's just like BaB. He would come up with some retardedly complicated plot and even if it involved him dying it would still be him winning because he came up with the plan. That's exactly the way his twisted mind works. And you all know it.

Yes, if it would make the two remaining Mafia look innocent I think that's exactly something that BaB would orchestrate, and indeed did orchestrate in my opinion.

Vampyr · 06-17-2009, 03:16 PM

But Dylflon never has, nor does he now, look innocent.

thatmariolover · 06-17-2009, 03:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vampyr

But Dylflon never has, nor does he now, look innocent.

Which is why I voted for him.

Vampyr · 06-17-2009, 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thatmariolover

Which is why I voted for him.

Yes but now, especially after the last few posts, you look much, much more guilty. Plus you -did- vote for Jeepnut last time, which I find more likely a sign of being in the mafia than some convoluted scheme that BaB supposedly concocted which involved the rest of the Mafia voting for him in order to gain the trust of everyone else.

If that had been the plan, the votes wouldn't have went in at the last second, either.

thatmariolover · 06-17-2009, 03:43 PM

How do I look more guilty? Because I pointed out some interesting coincidences? That doesn't make me guilty - it makes me honest. You on the other hand are only interested in shifting the blame to me because I pointed a flashlight on you. You didn't even act like I was guilty until I brought your name into the matter. So if you've got something to say then say it.

But it seems like you're more interested in bringing down the people who are suspicious of you than you are in bringing down the Mafia.

Vampyr · 06-17-2009, 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thatmariolover

How do I look more guilty? Because I pointed out some interesting coincidences? That doesn't make me guilty - it makes me honest. You on the other hand are only interested in shifting the blame to me because I pointed a flashlight on you. You didn't even act like I was guilty until I brought your name into the matter. So if you've got something to say then say it.

But it seems like you're more interested in bringing down the people who are suspicious of you than you are in bringing down the Mafia.

Um, yes I did act like you were guilty before this. I listed you, Nighthawk, and Swan.

I changed my vote to that tornado guy after you and nighthawk posted about BaB tricking you, because he tried the same thing on me and I felt you might be telling some truth.

But then you flipped out for some reason, which brought my attention back to you.

Which has be wondering two things:

Why would you do that if my vote wasn't currently on you?

This either means that tornado is the other mafia and you needed to protect him, or you are a villager. But if you are a villager it doesn't make sense to bring so much attention to yourself with a weird and far fetched theory.