Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Which is superior?

[birdman]

Originally Posted by Aladuf

Joke character? No, we all know that GNR wins at Knockin' on Heavens door. Just because it's your precious Bob Dylan doesn't mean that he's the best at everything.

GNR wins at being so ridiculous it's good, but that doesn't make it better than the original.

He's not "my precious". If I had the choice, I would've taken Clapton's version. I'd take Clapton over Dylan any day.