Against All Odds: Which is superior?

[Dyne]

It's hard to weigh the Phil Collins version.. is the studio version much different?

Out of those three, I'd say Phil Collins.

I can't stand Postal Service in general.

[Angrist]

Originally Posted by Dyne

It's hard to weigh the Phil Collins version.. is the studio version much different?

Studio version has a band kicking in halfway. It's a bit better in my opinion.

The Postal Service version is special, but a bit boring. Mariah always annoyes me, also with this cover.

[bobcat]

MC was great, PC was the best.