Of course NGC games come out on top for you... You wouldn't be D-realJos if that wasn't the case
I personally havn't seen enough of stuff from E3 to judge... But I thought the few screenshots of MGS3 looked amazing... And those were just screenshots...
As for RE4... the graphics are nice, but the screenshots I've seen PRIOR to E3 (I havn't seen any from E3) had very bland enviornments, IMO... They were like cold, lonely looking stone hallways... then like... a cold, lonely looking stone room with arches... and fences and stuff... o.O I hope the enviornments have a bit more variety than that... I need to check out the E3 video though...