MAFIA Scooby Doo Round 2

[Combine 017]

I have a few theorys up in the air.
Lets say Earl isnt mafia and hes right about Schadenfreude.
So we vote him off, and if he is mafia, then we know BaBs can be trusted, but if he isnt then BaBs was wrong and theres a good chance he is mafia so we vote him off next round. We can worry about Manas shenanigans later. Sound good to anyone else?

!retract Jeepnut


!vote Schadenfreude

[BreakABone]

Originally Posted by Combine 017

I have a few theorys up in the air.
Lets say Earl isnt mafia and hes right about Schadenfreude.
So we vote him off, and if he is mafia, then we know BaBs can be trusted, but if he isnt then BaBs was wrong and theres a good chance he is mafia so we vote him off next round. We can worry about Manas shenanigans later. Sound good to anyone else?

!retract Jeepnut


!vote Schadenfreude

There's one hole in your theory, but I'll bite

If Schadenfreude is innocent, I'll take the fall and even vote for myself.

[ZebraRampage]

Originally Posted by Combine 017

I have a few theorys up in the air.
Lets say Earl isnt mafia and hes right about Schadenfreude.
So we vote him off, and if he is mafia, then we know BaBs can be trusted, but if he isnt then BaBs was wrong and theres a good chance he is mafia so we vote him off next round. We can worry about Manas shenanigans later. Sound good to anyone else?

!retract Jeepnut


!vote Schadenfreude

During these first two rounds it seems like BaB has been a subject of mistrust, so maybe it would be good to clear this up. Schadenfreude also has the most votes so far, and nobody else is standing out, so I'm thinking I'll go with him too. Also, he has been really quiet, which is characteristic of the mafia being low key, as was said previously in this topic. I just can't remember who said it.

I think any vote is a shot in the dark too, but since there's a majority forming that has some theory behind it in what combine said, then I'll join.

Jeepnut, how do my theories read like a smoke screen? What I said about mana was very simplified. I know I changed my mind, but I did it because I really started to think he was joking. I don't know what else I can say about it.


!vote Schadenfreude