Mafianic 815 Round 3: Innocence lost

[GameMaster]

Congrats your 4,000th post.

[Yoda9864]

Originally Posted by BreakABone

Why is everyone moving against Fox?
I mean he voted Swan first round but really had nothing to go on. And it was his friend. I would have voted for my friend as well.
He defended Typhoid second round.

And I hate to say this, but is there a Canadian biase in the voting?

So you're trying to get some votes taken off of your Others teammate??

Mission accomplished.
!retract Fox 6
!vote BaB

[Professor S]

Originally Posted by BreakABone

Why is everyone moving against Fox?
I mean he voted Swan first round but really had nothing to go on. And it was his friend. I would have voted for my friend as well.
He defended Typhoid second round.

And I hate to say this, but is there a Canadian biase in the voting?

I have fully explained why we are voting against Fox6, due to his shenanigans during the Typhoid voting debate. Your refusal to accept this logical progession of thought now casts a curious eye at yourself. Where logic fails, there lies an Other desperately trying to save his and his compatriots collective asses.

Vigilante, I recommend you press the nose of your pistol against the back of this man's head. Don't pull the trigger... squeeze it

Your boy Fox is going down, son, and your ass is next. If not this round via vigilante, next round by vote. We have separated the kernel from the chaff, and now its only a matter of time before the Others are torn from this island as a splinter is torn from a finger.

[manasecret]

Professor S's logic is even worse than mine last round. This round, however, my logic is impeccable.

I think my line of thinking from last round has proven a house of cards, and as I said in Round 2, I think Fox 6's reaction to being targeted in that round with anger/exasperation makes him look innocent. My correspondence with him privately also seems to corroborate that.

Professor S, on the other hand, led the charge against Typhoid last round. He is again leading the charge this round. He seems far too eager to kill another without much thought to reason. Despite what he says about fully explaining his reason, he really hasn't. Read his posts.

Plus, his guarantee of letting us vote for him next round if Fox 6 is indeed innocent, is not much of an offer. I believe he is orchestrating a sacrifice of himself for the greater Other cause. One more round of ONLY survivor deaths, after two rounds of it, would be well worth it for the Others in exchange for Prof. S's sacrifice next round.

My guess is he's guilty. I !vote Professor S.

[Professor S]

Originally Posted by manasecret

I think my line of thinking from last round has proven a house of cards, and as I said in Round 2, I think Fox 6's reaction to being targeted in that round with anger/exasperation makes him look innocent. My correspondence with him privately also seems to corroborate that.

My comments and logic against Fox6 have nothing todo with his voting in the round, but his accusation against logical reasoning for voting in the face of little evidence.

Professor S, on the other hand, led the charge against Typhoid last round. He is again leading the charge this round. He seems far too eager to kill another without much thought to reason. Despite what he says about fully explaining his reason, he really hasn't. Read his posts.

I have explained more than a few times the reasoning behind the Typhoid vote, and I am not the one who led the charge, in fact, I was a late but boistrous adopter of the voting.

There ius reason behind the coting, juyst not much evidence, and at this point, with no Other having been exposed yet, there isn;t much evidence to go on except for the refusal to accept logical boting based on what little information we have. I agree, READ MY POSTS. Based on the information we have, these are the best choices, because there was no logical reason to accuse those that voted for Typhoid as his posting habits were abnormal.

Now I may be wrong, and I accept that, but based on what little we know Fox6 is THE BEST CHOICE and I have to think you know this.

Plus, his guarantee of letting us vote for him next round if Fox 6 is indeed innocent, is not much of an offer. I believe he is orchestrating a sacrifice of himself for the greater Other cause. One more round of ONLY survivor deaths, after two rounds of it, would be well worth it for the Others in exchange for Prof. S's sacrifice next round.

Poor logic. By your argument, I have taken an enormous risk that has almost no chance of succeeding if I'm an Other. If I'm an Other, then I'm just boned, and not only that, my recurring supporters have essentially been isolated and exposed even if a few Survivors tagged along. Its a no win situation if I'm an Other, and you know it.

My guess is he's guilty. I !vote Professor S.

My guess is, you're one of the few remaining Others that haven't been exposed, and you are all desperately trying to save your own skins by any stretch of logic you can reach for.

The truth is, either way all the Others are screwed if I'm voted off. My identity will be exposed, and then EVERYONE will be able to identify those that worked together to stop my leadership on this vote and you'll be winnowed down in the next few rounds. Game over.

So... VOTE ME OFF NOW IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE ME. Or you Others can kill me... and prove my point. Any way this vote shakes out, the good guys win.

The only way this works out for the Others, is if Fox6 in fact is not an Other, and then we're back at step one, but the fight I am getting on this vote makes that chance seem less and less likely by the minute.

[BreakABone]

I still hold by my judgment that the Others will be smart.

Hide under the radar. Vote for people who don't have a chance of being voted off.

Have us kill off each other while they laugh.

Who has participated in every discussion but voted against the majority?

[Teuthida]

Looks like the fluffy tailed one is a goner. I'm not so sure he's actually an other...but I'll keep with my theme of suspicion of fluffy tailed mammals.

!vote Fox 6

[manasecret]

Originally Posted by Professor S

I have explained more than a few times the reasoning behind the Typhoid vote, and I am not the one who led the charge, in fact, I was a late but boistrous adopter of the voting.

You said from the beginning that you thought the Vigilante would knock off Typhoid. While not a direct vote, coming from you and your influence, that's as good as a vote against Typhoid and you know it.

But my logic has been flawed so far, so I will take someone else's advice this round. I think BaB's point that the Others would be quiet is a good point. That would rule out both Prof. S and Fox 6.

I !retract Professor S.

I !vote jeepnut.

[BreakABone]

Jeebsus this does not look good for Fox
If he was an Other, he has me fooled.

Fox 6- 10
Jeepnut- 3
Germie- 1
Bond- 1
Aladuf- 1
BaB- 1

[manasecret]

Oops, BaB just posted the vote count.

[Bond]

!Clarification I would like to point out that many members who voted for Fox within that six-string-of-people have not been playing the game fairly. They have either been posting hardly at all, or have only been posting to simply vote.

!Retract The Germanator

!Vote jeepnut

[Bube]

Originally Posted by Bond

!Clarification I would like to point out that many members who voted for Fox within that six-string-of-people have not been playing the game fairly. They have either been posting hardly at all, or have only been posting to simply vote.

!Retract The Germanator

!Vote jeepnut

I was sleeping, then I had to go to school to get expelled, give me a break Bond!

I have to say, with all this talking going on, I'm quite suspicious of BaB (yes, you know why! ), Prof S and manasecret.

BaB's always a mystery. And mana and Prof's argument may just be a game. I'm not saying anything though. I currently stand by my vote.

[Bond]

What the hell, why did you get expelled?

[BreakABone]

Originally Posted by Bube

I was sleeping, then I had to go to school to get expelled, give me a break Bond!

I have to say, with all this talking going on, I'm quite suspicious of BaB (yes, you know why! ), Prof S and manasecret.

BaB's always a mystery. And mana and Prof's argument may just be a game. I'm not saying anything though. I currently stand by my vote.

Well, I was up with you.
It was YOU who screwed it up or have you forgotten?

[Bube]

Originally Posted by Bond

What the hell, why did you get expelled?

Long story.. But I was in a military school, and I didn't want to be in the military anymore - I want to go to a normal med school. The only way to get out of a military school is to get expelled. I failed two classes and got kicked out. I wanted it to happen I hope I can get into another school though.. (not because I was expelled, that doesn't pose a problem - I hope the school's I apply to don't get better applications than mine)

Originally Posted by BreakABone

Well, I was up with you.
It was YOU who screwed it up or have you forgotten?

Yes, I do. But I really don't know what difference it would've made. It should've been a leap of faith!