Lost finale

[BlueFire]

The more I think about it, the more I really enjoyed the season finale. I was thinking about a couple of things, though:

- In one of the 'flash-forwards', jack tells the chief of surgery guy to find his father to see how drunk he is... but his dad is dead. Was this Jack just talking **** or is there a possibility he is alive?

- Jacob.... what?

-About my comments on Locke: I thought he was great the first season and 1st half of the second season, but his continuing feuds with Jack and his 'mystical connection' with the island got pretty lame. That's just me. I did enjoy the episode with Sawyer and Locke's father.

- How do you guys feel about Charlie's death?

[Typhoid]

Originally Posted by BLueFire

- How do you guys feel about Charlie's death?

I felt it was friggin' due.
I was wondering how long they'd carry on the "Charlie's going to die, but not yet" thing for - to the point you'd think they're ****ing with you and you think he actually wont die.

I like how he didn't just die, but went out with something important to give to the next season.


PS. Why didnt he just leave the room, and lock the door after he's out?

[BlueFire]

Originally Posted by Typhoid

PS. Why didnt he just leave the room, and lock the door after he's out?

rofl I was thinking that, too. Maybe he just HAD to die.

[Null]

Originally Posted by BLueFire

rofl I was thinking that, too. Maybe he just HAD to die.

well what i was thinking when i saw it, is he did it to save desmond, because penny was on the line, desmond woulda risked it to have a chance to talk to her. and if charlie ran out and shut the door desmond could have just opened it. only locking it from the inside coulda stoped him




that was just my initial impression of it. but hey, thats life, people always do things that you can step back and say, hey, why didnt you just do this?


the better question, was why didnt he just let the room fill up then swim out the broken window. unless they plan to have him back next season and say thats what he did. never know.

[Typhoid]

Originally Posted by Null

the better question, was why didnt he just let the room fill up then swim out the broken window. unless they plan to have him back next season and say thats what he did. never know.

The window was too tiny.
MAYBE CHARLIE IS THE ISLAND.


Who knows.
Lost is ****ed up.
It will either end up being one of the best shows ever made, or [depending on the ending] one of the worst, and stupidest ever.

[Null]

window was too tiny? maybe for hurley to get through, but chairlie could easily swim through with room to spare. watch it again and see.


even if the next 3 seasons went down the crapper. the first 3 will still stand as some of the best television i've ever seen.

which i doubt they'll mess this one up. they have it planned out. 48 episodes left, they know the ending, every episode left should be building towards it.
with alias, they tried to extend it and keep it going past the point where it shoulda ended and it got really crappy towards the end. i think they're correcting that mistake with this show

[Typhoid]

Originally Posted by Null

i think they're correcting that mistake with this show

I have a terrible feeling the last season, or last 2 seasons will be them off the island, with flashbacks to the island.

Because after the finale, I dont see how they can keep it going on the island for another couple seasons.

[Dyne]

Originally Posted by BLueFire

The more I think about it, the more I really enjoyed the season finale. I was thinking about a couple of things, though:

- In one of the 'flash-forwards', jack tells the chief of surgery guy to find his father to see how drunk he is... but his dad is dead. Was this Jack just talking **** or is there a possibility he is alive?

Well god knows how the real Sawyer got on the Island, and then there were all those times that Jack saw his dad, and the casket was empty. Something's going on there.

- Jacob.... what?

Yeah I don't even know. What about the bird that said Hurley's name a while ago? That was weird.

-About my comments on Locke: I thought he was great the first season and 1st half of the second season, but his continuing feuds with Jack and his 'mystical connection' with the island got pretty lame. That's just me. I did enjoy the episode with Sawyer and Locke's father.

I haven't had any qualms with him, but it was pretty lame how he stood down when somebody answered the phone on the other end.

- How do you guys feel about Charlie's death?

It was... different.


So I mainly think that what should have happened in the episode: John should've shot Jack. That would have made him badical. The tension just felt without purpose without him shooting Jack. And it would also add more questions about the flashforwards.

Charlie also should've had a more urgent death. As it stands, it just felt lame.