The best home made lightsaber duel ever

[Fox 6]

I prefer the first to be honest. definitely better.

Edit: i also agree the lightsaber effect in the second was sub par compared to the first.
And Mugen the first one is definitely more star warsy than the second. I mean the second one had that whole WWII sub plot that is untrue to star wars. So i see that in retrospect the first one indeed has more of a star wars-esque feeling.

I agree that the first one was just a couple of kids fighting, but it just felt star wars. For me the big turn off to the seoncd was that whole WWII thing, that made it feel so un-star wars.