Stonecutter's 2005 NFL Playoff pool

[Professor S]

Originally Posted by Stonecutter

Would I rather have Brady, Culpepper, Pennington, Brady, Vick, Brady, Bulger a healthy McNair or Tom Brady. Yes.

Exactly where the hell do you get Vick from? What has he ever won? How many 300 yard games has he ever thrown? How many times this season has his team scored over 30 points?

This myth that Vick is an elite player bugs the hell out of me, so let me set the record straight...

Michael Vick is below average

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/foo.../players/5448/

These numbers plus one playoff victory must add up to an elite NFL player And don't even start in on his ability to run, because no running questerback has ever done anything in the playoffs. Ask Randall Cunningham.

[KillerGremlin]

The numbers show that Manning does much better indoors.

Dan Marino had great numbers too. How many superbowls did he win?

The Patriots are the favorite for this weeks game, but why is that? Is it because Manning threw for 450 yards against the Broncos last week or that Manning just won the MVP or that Manning just beat Marino's touchdown record?

We'll see how he handles under pressure in the cold.