New Bands Round 1 Metallica vs. Neutral Milk Hotel

[Typhoid]

This one shouldnt even be a match, although, their last CD kind of bombed, but it didnt stop me from buying it.



Sanitarium, Leave me be. Sanitarium, leave me alone.



Look at me, Im + repping people who vote for Metallica!

[Null]

They will win and get my vote because of thier older stuff.

if this was based on thier newest album only, i'd sign up 100 names and vote against them 100 times. because that album was a PIECE OF SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIT!



however, luckily they made many more great albums that outweigh that last one. 'The Unforgiven' one of my all time fav songs from any band, actually right up there with 'November Rain' from GNR

my votes for metallica.

[DimHalo]

I haven't heard new stuff from them. It is really that bad?

[Typhoid]

Originally Posted by jeepnut's slave

I haven't heard new stuff from them. It is really that bad?

Download or find St.Anger ( their newest album) Its not super good, but its not horrible IMO.

They tried too hard to be how they used to be and sound how they used to sound.

Still "Frantic" is the best track on that album IMO.

[Null]

st.anger is 'talerable' at points. but the album sucks. they tried to sound like they did long ago but failed. most of that CD i cant even say is 'music'

[Seth]

Neutral Milk Hotel


Just because Metallica isn't metallica anymore. And, I've never been a huge fan. I like some of their older stuff but I did listen to their latest album and it really really sucked. Plus, they were the most vocal against napster.

[The Germanator]

Neutral Milk Hotels "In the Aeroplane Over the Sea" is one of the greatest albums of all time. This is no contest...in NMH's favor. Metallica was OK, but they are really not anything special. While Jeff Magnum is a superb and brilliant songwriter...I encourage you to listen to their music. You'll like it...

Plus I met Julian Koster who plays the singing saw in NMH, and he's a cool guy.