*thinks* There ARE a few quick-fixes for this type of situation.
Brought to you with smilie additions courtesy of the Bubeedut and Mr. Nobody Alliance of Cuba.
1) Flip a fine, two-sided coin (assuming you have a coin with exactly two sides... no more). In a group chat with both BF and Dyne, you tell them to choose a side and keep that side to themselves (we don't want
cheating). Then, you flip the coin, say what the side is, and ask which of the two (BF and Dyne) had chosen that side. *scratches his head*

Something about this little plan doesn't seem right...
2) Have an auction. Whichever of the two empties more of their wallets to the RP Charity will get my vote... and all the other 4000 or so added into the poles.
3) Rematch... but in the ring!
4) Forget about, disqualify both, and continue. Plain enough, no?
What I think may have happened, you ask? Perhaps someone's lousy Mac wasn't loading properly, or the forum wasn't recieving info correctly... that is, someone could have submitted their vote continuously out of frustration (say... 4000 times!) and finally gave up to find the next morning that every single one went through.
That, or Dyne didn't care and gave himself votes for the fun of it.
*shrugs* Either way.