GT Starwars mafia, better than TV

[Ric]

Originally Posted by BreakABone

Either way you were dead, if he killed Combine, you would have lost by vote.

That's assuming that if he hadn't killed me he would have gone for combine, who's to say he would have done that? Say he went for someone else all together. In which case it would have come down to a 50/50 split chance on the coin toss.

Fyacin? Who was your second choice had you not taken me out? Just out of interest.

[BreakABone]

Actually since we are asking Fyacin questions.

Why didn't he kill anyone on the first and third day?
I assumed he was playing it safe, but that's not the fun of Mafia.

[Bond]

Okay, I hate to limit speech, but to preserve the integrity of the game, I think we have to restrict what people can or cannot say a little more.

Past players and observers are allowed to post commentary on what is going on in the game, but posting your theories and / or making recommendations as to what players should do is not allowed. Posts should be reactionary to what is going on in the game, if that makes sense.

Again, I hate to do this, but I have to make sure the game remains fair.

[Typhoid]

I honestly think there should be NO comment on the game if you are out of the game or dead. At all.
Say the game is great, you wish you were in it.
But as soon as you start saying who to vote for etc, and who you're suspicious of, you start influencing the game, and I don't believe that's fair.

I will not lock it, because it's not my game, but I highly suggest that this thread be locked, Bond.


Edit: It seems my Whiskey sight didn't let me see your post.

[C.H]

Originally Posted by Bond

Okay, I hate to limit speech, but to preserve the integrity of the game, I think we have to restrict what people can or cannot say a little more.

Past players and observers are allowed to post commentary on what is going on in the game, but posting your theories and / or making recommendations as to what players should do is not allowed. Posts should be reactionary to what is going on in the game, if that makes sense.

Again, I hate to do this, but I have to make sure the game remains fair.

Ahh no fun, but i understand and was kind of expecting it. I may well participate next time.

I think all the films should be remade with these state of the arts sound effects

[Ric]

I can not really see that I have said anything that would ruin the game. Unless Fyacin's answer to my questions is someone that is still in the game.

And I was speaking about the round I was alive in, I first predicted BaB was evil and sowed the first seeds of doubt. Now that has come to fruition I have been proven correct. So why can I not comment on that? all I said was, I told you so.

I have not offered any personal opinions on the game since I died. I do not want to interfere with the game. I do not see that I have done anything wrong.

I believe this thread should be open for those non- (not ex) players to express their opinions, otherwise the game is kind of restricted from the rest of the members in the forum. How can they be expected to say nothing about what is probably the best thing going on at GT at the moment?

[Bond]

It's nothing that you personally did, Ric. It's just having past members discuss theories and whatnot opens up a whole can of worms, and could very well adversely affect the game.

It's unfortunate that there can't be much discussion by members voted out, but the game is based on trust / secrecy, so there has to be some of that even when you're no longer playing.

There will be a post-game thread, though, where everyone can freely talk about the game.

[Angrist]

Edited due to rules violation. - Bond

[Ric]

Ok so can anyone explain this -


Changed to -


Why in the hell did this get changed? It's fucking stupid and makes no sense. Anikin would have been an old man by then. So what? he dies and becomes young again when the other jedi do not. What a load of crap.

My avatar supports the true vader. George Lucas is a bloody moron.

And now it's 'Spot The Difference'

[Angrist]

Hm his harmonica seems a bit smaller in the 2nd pic.
Also: why the pointy head? Was his mask too tight?

[Bond]

Originally Posted by Angrist

Edited due to rules violation.

Angrist, you can't communicate with Ric (a dead player) according to the Rules Thread:

You may not communicate regarding the game with someone who is dead, nor may dead players communicate about the game with active players.

[Angrist]

Ehm apparently my weird sense of humor is incomprehensible. Ric never told me he was mafia.
Hm I had a short chat with BaB after he died... I said 'bastard!' So that wasn't allowed either... Sorry for that. I didn't get any smarter though.

If both active and dead players are allowed to post here, isn't that communicating? Slippery slope...

Anyway, I don't care that much, but I'm just saying.

[Typhoid]

Originally Posted by Angrist

If both active and dead players are allowed to post here, isn't that communicating? Slippery slope...

If you want to make a snarky point, start thinking first.

Yes, it's communicating. Communicating in this thread is fine. As we are doing right now. I am communicating to you. You are going to communicate back. Communicating about game specifics and your theories/hunches is not, if you were in the game and have been killed - as you would still be able to influence the game.

The reason people who haven't been in the game can talk about it, is because they didn't build up networks of trust and alliances within the game, so their suspicious probably won't go anywhere. However if you're in the game and were in an alliance with person B, C and E, and say that person A and D are together, the 3 people you were with will more likely believe you.

[Ric]

Ok there's half an hour left before the game ends. No activity for quite a while and everyone has cast their votes. They currently stand at -

thatmariolover - 5
tornadothrasher - 2
Dylflon - 2
BlueFire - 1
Teuthida - 1
Bube - 1

Will we see any action in the closing 30 mins? I am watching to find out at least.

[jeepnut]

Looks like TML's not going to present his case further. I think we know who our next village death will be. The only question now is, who will the mafia kill?