The ultimate question: Schwarzenegger or Stallone?

[Dyne]

Let's say this alien came from out of nowhere and had a memory-erasing ray, and for some reason or another, wanted to destroy one actor's career entirely by erasing the memory of his existance. The movies they were in would never exist (or end up being kind of like Predator 2). Who would you choose to keep?

I know, ridiculous situation, but on my run today, I decided that I can't really choose between the two.

[Jonbo298]

Stallone for me, but only due to the fact of that awesome scene in the new Rambo movie (.50 cal scene which I won't spoil).

[Angrist]

Schwarzenegger for sure. I never really liked the Stalone movies, they're too raw for me. I also find Stalone very uninspiring. Schwarzenegger his face etc. just fascinates me.

And wow, the sky outside is gorgeously pink... Sorry, that has nothing to do with the thread.

[Dyne]

Originally Posted by Angrist

Schwarzenegger for sure. I never really liked the Stalone movies, they're too raw for me. I also find Stalone very uninspiring. Schwarzenegger his face etc. just fascinates me.

And wow, the sky outside is gorgeously pink... Sorry, that has nothing to do with the thread.

Yeah, I was about to say.. his face? I thought you meant his throbbing pecs.

EDIT: Huh, it looks like they're finally doing a movie together. As soon as Arnold's term ends.

http://www.cinematical.com/2006/02/1...nally-team-up/

[GameMaster]

I would have to say Stallone.

And I feel the opposite of Angrist. Stallone was very emotionally moving as the character of Rocky in those films. And all of them except the fifth were very inspiring too. Each time I watch one, it makes me want to obtain six-packs abs and look so super hot.

[Fox 6]

Originally Posted by Jonbo298

Stallone for me, but only due to the fact of that awesome scene in the new Rambo movie (.50 cal scene which I won't spoil).

how can you spoil graphic violence? :P


well this one guy gets shot and dies!!!!!!!!!!! And this other guy he shoots with the gun and hes all like AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


i can has benefit of doubt plz?

[Aladuf]

Originally Posted by Jonbo298

Stallone for me, but only due to the fact of that awesome scene in the new Rambo movie (.50 cal scene which I won't spoil).

Are you referring to the one where it looks like you're playing Gears of War?!

[Renwood]

Schwarzenegger brings me more dumb entertainment from his horrible movies, but was also the Terminator. Stallone made some movies that I truly enjoyed, and then pissed on their legacies.

tie

[Dyne]

Ok, I made an option for those of us who can't decide.

[jeepnut]

Originally Posted by Dyne

Ok, I made an option for those of us who can't decide.

Cop-out.

I can't think of one Stallone movie that I really care about.

Governator for the win.

[KillerGremlin]

Schwarzenegger has a pretty manly resume.

T1, T2, T3
Predator
Total Recall
Last Action Hero
True Lies
Conan The Barbarian

and he's been in a slew of mildly entertaining and crappy films, most notably his laugh-out-loud-bad roll as Mr. Freeze.

Stallone is cool, but I'm not a Rocky fan and the Terminator series blows Rambo out of the water.

Arnie all the way.

[Dylflon]

There really needs to be a "They both suck" option.

[Renwood]

Originally Posted by Dylflon

There really needs to be a "They both suck" option.

Almost Vancouver

oh I get it

[Vampyr]

Schwarzenegger, easily.

Terminator 2 and Predator are two of my favorite movies.

[thatmariolover]

Stallone had potential but I don't think it was realized in the same way as Schwarzenegger.