Tribal Council #1

Neo · 01-18-2004, 02:04 AM

Vote one member out of the newly formed tribe.

Perfect Stu · 01-18-2004, 10:26 AM

my sh*t's already packed...

Rndm_Perfection · 01-18-2004, 05:55 PM

Hey, what the hell? I didn't get to give away immunity.

EDIT: Perhaps the schedule of this thing could be mixed around. If challenges are every three days... then

(in order of days, hypothetical):
1) Challenge
2) Challenge Results and Announce Immunity
3) Vote
4) Repeat 1-3

It'd give people time to group together and decide to vote for. Individual immunity is a lot different than tribe immunity. As tribes, people could know days ahead of time "IF we lose, we vote of this guy". In individual... you can't make any decisions until after immunity is declared. Otherwise, one's whole plan could be blown. And, since we're not on an island here, we need time enough to have a chance at being on between immunity and council.

Perfect Stu · 01-18-2004, 06:17 PM

if Individual Immunity can be given away, and Rndm is (was?) willing to give it to me...what's the deal?

Happydude · 01-18-2004, 07:03 PM

yeah...rndm is right...we need more time.

Vampyr · 01-18-2004, 07:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rndm

Hey, what the hell? I didn't get to give away immunity.

http://www.gametavern.net/forums/sho...8&postcount=18

Neo said they did it on occasion. So, since he didnt give you the opportunity to give it away, Im going to assume he isnt doing it for this game of survivor.

Rndm_Perfection · 01-18-2004, 07:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vampyr

http://www.gametavern.net/forums/sho...8&postcount=18

Neo said they did it on occasion. So, since he didnt give you the opportunity to give it away, Im going to assume he isnt doing it for this game of survivor.

It's on occasion because it's by choice. Neo did not say I could not give away immunity. Instead, he did not know who I wanted to give it to, if I wanted to give it away, or even if I was getting immunity. He just started tribal council before I got home from work. It's just an inconvenience and lack of communication.

And don't assume.

The Germanator · 01-18-2004, 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rndm_Perfection

It's on occasion because it's by choice. Neo did not say I could not give away immunity. Instead, he did not know who I wanted to give it to, if I wanted to give it away, or even if I was getting immunity. He just started tribal council before I got home from work. It's just an inconvenience and lack of communication.

And don't assume.

I don't understand your problem here...Neo is running this Survivor game, if he posted this poll with the survivors eligible to be voted off, then those are the survivors eligible to be voted off. Neo didn't say that you "could not" give away immunity, but that doesn't mean you are able to. Neo made the rules for this particular Survivor game, and never said that your way is how it would be done, so what's wrong?

I do agree with needing more time to vote though.

Vampyr · 01-18-2004, 07:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Germanator

I don't understand your problem here...Neo is running this Survivor game, if he posted this poll with the survivors eligible to be voted off, then those are the survivors eligible to be voted off. Neo didn't say that you "could not" give away immunity, but that doesn't mean you are able to. Neo made the rules for this particular Survivor game, and never said that your way is how it would be done, so what's wrong?

I do agree with needing more time to vote though.

Exactly.

And if you had ever watched survivor, rndm, you would know that not every game of survivor has allowed for them to hand off immunity to someone else. This is why I think when he said "they do that on occasion", he was refering to the game actually allowing a player to do that.

For example, the last survivor that was aired on television, Pearl Islands, allowed a player to pass it on.

The one before it didnt allow it to be done.

However, the one before THAT one did.

Get my point? Neo posted the poll without allowing you to pass it on. Therefore I rightfully assume that you're not allowed to pass it to anyone else.

Neo never said you couldnt pass it on, but I dont recall him saying you could, either.

It would be nice to have more time, though.

Neo · 01-19-2004, 12:20 AM

Giving away of immunity was never intended to be part of this challenge. It may or not be a part of future challenges.

The polls have a life of 24 hours. Though usually I close them early once the result is known regardless if all votes have been cast.

And Perfect Stu has been voted out of the tribe.