What would happen to earth if humans vanished?

BlueFire · 07-16-2007, 01:05 AM

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/19762077/site/newsweek/

Good read.

GameMaster · 07-16-2007, 01:38 AM

A fascinating and at the same time daunting thought.

Wouldn't it be scary if some extremists carried this out with a virus that would wipe us out?

Dylflon · 07-16-2007, 02:08 AM

Yeah, we pretty much wreck everything up.

Professor S · 07-16-2007, 09:12 AM

Ah, humanity as a disease... how trite. I'm always shocked how environmentalists seem to forget that human beings are a natural part of Earth's environment. Lower life forms are not "pure" and we do not "taint" them. They use their environment just like we do. Beaver's build dams, carnivores eat other animals, the world turns and goes on.

My favorite part is how nice they assume everyone thinks a world without humans would be wonderful. How is that wonderful? WE DON'T EXIST. Besides, how an Weisman be so sure about how the world would be without us? We have great impact on this planet and on other species. Assuming vrything would simply fall back into balance assumes that the other animals won't assume new power roles in this new humanless world.

We are not on this planet to serve this planet. We are here to thrive and flourish, and the best way towards this goal is to conserve the planets resources for our own uses and survival, not simply because the earth is inherently "better" without us. These idiotic notions of "everyone agree to have one kid, OK? That cool? Great, deal." need to be exposed for what they are: Nonsense.

Dylflon · 07-17-2007, 01:14 PM

Hey guys, Professor S thinks humanity is A-OK!

What a flippin eco-terrorist!

Professor S · 07-17-2007, 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dylflon

What a flippin eco-terrorist!

I love that term. Such incredible color and hyperbole to describe something that doesn't exist. There are no humans who are trying to get what they want from the world by "terrorizing" it. The planet cannot experience fear. It is not self-aware.

And did you even read what I wrote? I believe in conservation and balance. We need to conserve this planet's resources, and all its resources, including oil, coal, air, water, wood, stone, etc. These are all resources we need to exist. Without this planet humans don't exist, and I apologize if this is policially incorrect, but I like existing. I suppose that makes me some evil, nature hating monger. Earth is not inherently better or worse than we are. It has no idea of good and bad. It is a ball of rock, liquids and gasses that we live on. If we don't conserve it, we die. To me thats the best reason there is to take positive environmental action. Notice I say "positive" action.

This also doesn't translate into the need to "punish" humanity for its sins against mother earth. Thats simply childish nonsense. These anthropomorphic ideas of how pure the world is compared to humanity are rediculous. Listen to how you sound! "Eco-Terrorist"? What does that even mean? Do you know? Or are you just repeating some sound-byte friendly nonsense coined by another babbling fount of self-hatred?

Get past your anger and start thinking of logical, reasonable solutions to pollution. Force has never worked. Make people want to do their part by making it attractive, concevnient and affordable, and the populace will follow you.

Saying "One kid per couple"? That sounds wonderful, but it has the ame downfall as all other fundamentalist based concepts. They require massive amounts of dogamatic kool-aid that no one wants to drink.

I await your next 2-3 line answer that calls me another fictional insult.

Bond · 07-18-2007, 12:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dylflon

What a flippin eco-terrorist!

Haha.

Anyway, whether or not we're here to serve the Earth or our own selfish endeavors seems up for debate to me, but I do believe we, as humans, are here to help eachother. And perhaps in our efforts to help our own kind we must also help the environment, animals, etc. Really a win-win for everyone involved.

But the insinuation that animals would be better off without us seems ridiculous to me. Didn't these people watch Planet Earth? The majority of all animals (unless they're domesticated... by humans!) live a life of prolonged suffering. They spend their entire time finding food, reproducing and raising their young. Fortunately for us, we were able to break past that mold. Perhaps many humans are still living a life of suffering, but it seems to me the majority of us are not, and that has to be a good thing.

KillerGremlin · 07-17-2007, 01:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GameMaster

A fascinating and at the same time daunting thought.

Wouldn't it be scary if some extremists carried this out with a virus that would wipe us out?

12 Monkeys

good movie, go see it!

KillerGremlin · 07-17-2007, 01:45 PM

It boils down to neccessity. If you subscribe to the religion thing we were pretty much put on earth to flourish and serve [interchangeable-super being].

If you want to look at ecosystems and nature....well, I don't think there's anything natural about driving cars and building nukes. The biggest problem we will face is overpopulation. Disease, famine and war will all be the result of overpopulation. On the plus side...once we become overpopulated, disease and famine (nature) will kill us off to even the tables. War is a man made thing, go man!

it's a cynical outlook, but i have faith that we will die and the earth will go back to its neutral state. that or the Apocalypse will take place. 2012 baby.

Professor S · 07-17-2007, 01:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KillerGremlin

It boils down to neccessity. If you subscribe to the religion thing we were pretty much put on earth to flourish and serve [interchangeable-super being].

If you want to look at ecosystems and nature....well, I don't think there's anything natural about driving cars and building nukes. The biggest problem we will face is overpopulation. Disease, famine and war will all be the result of overpopulation. On the plus side...once we become overpopulated, disease and famine (nature) will kill us off to even the tables. War is a man made thing, go man!

it's a cynical outlook, but i have faith that we will die and the earth will go back to its neutral state. that or the Apocalypse will take place. 2012 baby.

My ideas aren't religious based, more survival based. But once again, I people are failing to see that humans are a part of nature! If we are natural, then are fruits are born of natural process!

That doesn't mean that they're necessarily beneficial in the long run, but they are natural. We need to stop viewing things as natural or unnatural and start analyzing them in terms of long term benefit to mankind in all ways. It is there that I think all minds will come to decent, logical comprimises.

KillerGremlin · 07-17-2007, 02:07 PM

I agree. Although I'm a heartless bastard...but if it's going to be me, or some berries and a cow and that pond over there, I'll take me. Be it divine intervention or not, there's no denying that humans are a product of nature thus making us natural.

I always thought it would be cool to go live on some island in a bamboo hut enjoying campfires under the stars every night and being at one with nature. Then I got the internet. Oh well...maybe on my honeymoon.

Angrist · 07-17-2007, 01:45 PM

I'm shocked that I would every say this

, but I have to agree a bit with Strangler here. I also believe the Earth is here for us. I believe in a God who created it for us. He did tell us to take care of it though. But humanity dying would be pointless.