The only games that scared me were errm like RE1 and 2 (cuz I was young) and the Silent Hill games (mainly the first)...
I think the scariest part in a SH game (although it was a cheap pop-out thing
) was in the alternate school locker room where something is tapping on the inside of a locker and you open it and it's empty (in the normal world there's a cat inside), then you turn around to leave and some other random locker just bursts open and a body falls out
And yes I've said that a million times before when it comes to scary parts in games, but still...
Oh yeah and... errmmm... Beetles popping out of the ground in Metroid Prime?
