http://gamespot.com/gamespot/features/all/bestof2002/
With over 100 categories, this will take you a long time to go through. Took me 45 minutes and I skipped a lot. Definately worth your time though, I think they do a good job overall. I'll let you guys read it yourselves before I say anything, so I dont spoil the surprise factor.
Note to mods: I wasnt sure what forum this belonged to, so feel free to move it if you feel it fits better someplace else.