I can see this thread going in a lot of directions....the first direction I can see is people quoting other people's piracy habits and applying their own moral beliefs which will result in some good arguing but it could also spiral into a good flame war.
So to keep things in good fun, at least for a little, perhaps everyone can clarify their own moral position in a context that does not involve quoting other members personal habits. Then, once there position is established...they can let it rip! I'm all for a good argument, but we need some foundations.
I'll throw out my first though...which is that I do like to OWN a physical copy of media. I like having my piece of plastic when it comes to a movie, music, or TV show. For me it is the ultimate form of ownership...I have the media, and I can do whatever I want with it.