Full disclosure, this is a game that is near to me. I mean I'll be frank, this remains my favorite game of the generation so I won't be completely unbiase here.
With that said, Super Mario Galaxy is the 2nd highest rated game of this generation (GTA IV is the first, which is why picked it), it won more than 20 Game of Year awards, and is generally heralded as the best Wii game so far.
And for some reason, I still think that this game is underrated, I mean maybe its just the people I talk with, but so many have never played this game nor complete the game. It is hardly ever held in the same light as major HD games. And almost certain most people won't mention it along the more fleshed out experiences or whatever.
With that said, Over/Under-Rated for Super Mario Galaxy?
