[Angrist]

Germy and his friends aren't doing a great job defending the captain. I don't think it shouldn't matter gamewise whether he's the captain or not. Saying he can't be crazy isn't an argument.
Besides, we know for sure that he has killed somebody. He still has the bloody club in his hand.

So based on what people have posted, I will change my vote.

!retract Uber_Paddler

!vote The Germanator