Oh no doubt I respect your opinion I just thought it would be cool if you could ellaborate more on it. It's cool. But just to clarify any misunderstanding,
the second video was an FX Project done for class. If it's sole intention was to capture the essence of Star Wars I'm pretty sure it would've been done differently.
I'm just saying the second video is a better DUEL because of the martial arts and stuff. I'm not saying it's a better video overall....
the whole point of this thread was about the Duel. In the end, to each his own. Both videos had great choreography and the first video ended really good with a lil trickery at the end. And I like how the second video's duel ended because it was very dramatic and stylish.
If you want to sift through a lot of home made star wars films go to theforce.net and take a gander at all the nice videos.
Actually I happened upon this piece.. what do you think of it:
http://download.theforce.net/theater...e/eotf_480.mov
Warning: 59megs