[Professor S]

What I loved about the first video is that they didn't just rely on quick and cgi acrobatics, which I thought made the fights in the latest movies suffer a bit. Plus, it had a great ghoreography which told a story and included good "force use" moments.

As for the second one, it had great acrobatics and sword play, but other than that it didn't strike me as being very Star Wars at all. It was like Crouching Tiger Hidden Matrix.

Overall, I thought the first was far superior in both concept and and keeping true to the source material.