View Single Post

Re: Star Wars *Spoilers*
Old 05-22-2005, 04:43 AM   #7
DeathsHand
Village Idiot
 
DeathsHand's Avatar
 
DeathsHand is offline
Location: Arlington, VA
Now Playing: Go Fish
Posts: 4,144
Default Re: Star Wars *Spoilers*

Quote:
Originally Posted by Typhoid
I admit, I would have liked it more if it showed him actually killing the children, but I guess implying is good enough.
Since the topic has a spoiler marking on it now, I'm not going to bother with another

I think not showing it was part of what made that scene as powerful as it was... I mean, you see that one kid kick some ass and then get blasted when Bail Organa arrives... And you do see Anakin kill a couple kids on the security hologram thing...

But neither of them were as powerful as when Anakin waltzed in the room, the kids asked him for help, he just stares and turns on his lightsaber... End of scene...

Both times I went, a few people (within earshot), as soon as the lightsaber came on, either gasped or muttered (in a shocked sorta way) something to the extent of "Is he gonna kill the kids!?"... I think actually showing it would've taken away a bit of it's effect...

Some things are better left implied or indirect-ish... Like love... "I'M SO IN LOVE!!!", "NO, IT IS I WHO IS SO IN LOVE WITH YOU!!!"...
  Reply With Quote