I agree with best next-gen and biggest disappointment. Microsoft showed a few games. I wish there was more then say 3 or 4 (I think thats how many were PLAYABLE) but thats just being picky for the most part. Full Auto was awesome to screw around with (from Sega).
Dissapointment - I too felt it badly. Nintendo keeps hyping up Revolution then fails to even give great detail about it claiming yet again its 'too uber to talk about' (not an exact quote

). Grow some hairy balls and give details to woo over the gamers at E3. Everyone is too busy drooling at PS3/360 and going 'Oh, Nintendo showed something?'
Granted, I am hyped for Revolution but I know nothing that really has grabbed me. Granted, being able to play past Nintendo games for maybe a small fee is fricken awesome but I want to see in-game shots of next-gen games. And for cripes sake, show the damn controller even if its prototype. What the hell is Microsoft/Sony gonna do about it? They will just call everything Nintendo shows a gimmick anyways. Maybe they grew so old and tired of calling Nintendo kiddy they decided to pickup the word gimmick for anything Nintendo tries to do outside the box.
Whew...anywho. Sorry for going off...
Tabula Rasa gets a huge nod from me. I heard a little bit about the game but after seeing how awesome it was for being basically an alpha of the game, its definitely one MMO I'll be watching for the next year.
Nintendogs gets a nod from me for DS best of show. That game is really addicting!!