Quote:
|
Originally Posted by thatmariolover
I really agree. HD-DVD is the way to go right now. Particularly when it comes to movies, HD-DVD is going to end up being more versatile because of its compatability with current DVD's, and the fact that it will support more compression formats than MPEG-2.
And usually I don't I agree with a lot of what Gekko says, but I'm thinking the guy who came up with these rumors is blowing smoke. Anybody could say what he's saying and be believed. Although, I'm not going to say he's outright wrong, I just don't think he's working with any more info than we've already got to come to his conclusions.
It's true, they really need to decide. But I personally think it's kind of unfair of Sony to place us in a position like this. They're releasing Blu-Ray before the HD-DVD format is going to be finalized and mass produced. So if Blu-Ray starts winning over the market, backwards compatability could go bye bye if the general consumers just go with Blu-Ray because it's out first.
But as you said, whatever format wins the war will be the one that I buy into.
|
Now that I got some actual time to write...
Yes, Blu-Ray has a larger capacity. Big deal. Over the years, chances are HD-DVD discs will either be released with a larger capacity, or a higher compression methoed will be developed. Do I think Blu-Ray will be a good disc? Of course, but I think it will go the way of the minidisc, and not really be adapted.
HD-DVD has the backwards compatability. They have already developed a laser than can read both blue and red laser discs. So when consumers buy their new HD-DVD player, they can still play their large DVD collection. Meanwhile, Blu-Ray lacks backwards compatability, and needs new production facilities to make the discs, and those ain't cheap.
When it comes time to sell it to the movie industry, I see them choosing HD-DVD.
As for the guy coming up with this stuff, everyone is assuming it will have a HD, an ethernet port, and everything else. He stole IGN's idea of gyros, you know he wouldn't have come up with it on his own. But he offers nothing new, nothing radical. It was the same thing last time with Dolphin. Everyone assumed it would have an LCD screen on the controller, so they people confirmed it would have a color LCD screen. When it didn't, they changed screen names.
Nintendo is not a company that is known to leak information to create hype. If it comes from developers who have the dev kits, then believe it, but don't get your heart set on it. If not, it's fake. The only time I've ever seen information leaked from Nintendo is when the GBA was revealed by a mag scan from Famitsu.