Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

I think we can all agree that both Keira and Natalie came from the same clone factory. If you could kidnap only one to take to your deserted island and make as your looooove slave who would it be. (I'm leaning towards Keira, she already has the wench role down)...:p

Natalie Portman:

















Keira Knightley:

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

2 words: Garden State.

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

Very close call, but Natalie having a more curvy, natural body edged Keira out.

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

Well actually I was taking a walk the other day and bumped into Keira down the road from my house, she ended up coming back to my place, so I have already had her ;)

And so I would say Natalie, especially if I look at that black and white photo. Where does she live in the US, I am coming over for a visit :lol:

EDIT: But I ended up going with Keira, partly because of the way the options were worded on the poll and partly because of the pirate thing.

EDIT 2: I just reaised you can see Natalie's tits in this pic.
Lies!

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

Hands down Keira.
A million times more attractive.

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

I honestly don't get the whole Natalie Portman thing...

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

It's not so much that she's hot, but that she's cute.

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

Keira Knightley would get my vote if she wasn't deathly thin (I saw those pictures...sheesh).

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

The gay vote goes to Keira

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

Portman went to Harvard. So got the whole brains thing


But I went with Knightley

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

Well... Natalie Portman has the looks and the brains, but her political views are a little wacky. Keira Knightley is attractive and interesting, but she is a tad anorexic. Natalie has been in better movies as well, although it is pretty close.

Natalie wins.

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

I feel a little biased cuz Natalie is in Star Wars. But I also prefer her curves to Knightly's none.

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

They both look pretty scrawny to me

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

I went with Natalie though I don't really know Keira's films all that well. I guess familiarity swung it for me.

Re: Keira Knightley vs. Natalie Portman
 

Keira needs a few pounds but out of the 2, she edges out just a bit. Sorry Bond :p