They were merely critiquing the additions to gameplay made through the transition from Dreamcast to the Cube. I tend to stick with the reviews based upon the *original* rendition of the game.

Well, you expect GameCube-worthy graphics... and you don't really get them....

Actually the graphics was the only thing they liked.

Ok... :unsure:

I played through Zelda:OoT, Mario 3, Goldeneye, Mario 64, Zelda:MM, and Madden franchise mode (:p) more than 4 times each, and I would slip it in and play each one again from the start without hesitation.

I played through Sonic Adventure 2 twice, and I cn't stand to play it anymore....

so your point is???

My point is that very many games get boring after you beat them. Only super games like Golden Eye and Super Smash Bros are still fun. At least that's my opinion.

Sonic games are usually very replayable though. I played through Sonic Advance over 6 times since I got it last saturday.

:eek: don't you sleep?

It's a pretty easy game (minus finding the chaos emeralds) and I have Sonic hooked up to my brain from the genesis day...and no, I don't sleep. *quacks like a duck and runs around in circles*

I agree... I played through Sonic 1, 2, and 3 at least 20 times each :D and I'd play them again if I ha the chance :D

probably because I'm just a big sonic fanboy ;)

but I only played through SA2 twice and I can't stand it...

maybe if they included the ability to have Supersonic in every level, and had not added the non-Sonic levels I would love it.

or maybe they could have left it 2d and brought talis back as a partner ;)

I miss the 2-d days :(

That's what we have the AGB for, remember?

AGB isn't good enough...

I'd rather them make a 2d Sonic game on a console that uses a full TV...

Me gots SA2 Battle :D Good game, better than the DC version. New Chao stuff ain't bad. Improved graphics are always nice, and finally another progressive scan game!

Here's a little tip, check the DC reviews of this game. The Nintendo reviewers are considering factors like graphics, expect them to be pushing GC to the limit when it's a DC port. Also adding new stuff, and making the game different than the DC game. Case in point, this is the DC game made better.

And I got my first Rouge level out of the way. w00t!

I'm guessing you haven't beat SA2 for Dreacast before

No, got about half way through on both stories. I was on a Knuckles and Rouge level, and there I stopped :D