SMS vs. SFA

[Nocturnal_LIGHT]

Does any1 have SFA and SMS, and can they tell me which one is better please?

[Crono]

it's all opinions, there really is no "better" game, you had best play them yourself and then judge it for yourself. someone might say sms is better while others would say sfa...

[Angrist]

Although I think SMS got better reviews.

[Jason1]

My brother having just gotten SFA yesterday, I now have both games. But I have barley gotten to play SFA yet, so as I get further into it, I will be able to make a better prediction on which I like better. (I havent even gotten to play as fox yet)

[Ginkasa]

They're not really very comparable games. SMS is a platformer while SFA is a an adventure game. Just choose whichever genre you like best.


*shrugs and walks away*

[DarkMaster]

i've played and beaten both SMS and SFA and i enjoyed SMS way more than SFA.

[Shadow_Link]

Though they're totally different games. I would just say, SMS, plain and simple. I had so much fun playing SMS, and it a somewhat challenging experience. The level design is also impeccable. SFA is a good game, but sadly, nothing great, or spectacular. The graphics are top notch, and everything seems very refined. But the game itself is not only monotonous, but it just doesn't bring anything new into the gaming world.

SFA would be a great game to show off graphically (though the water in SMS is some of the best in any game).

[GameMaster]

Super Mario Sushine

[CrOnO_LiNk]

Let me rate those 2 games...


Star Fox Adventures: 8.3/10

Super Mario Sunshine: 9.4/10



This is my opinion and I personally think most people prefer Mario than Star Fox Adventures. SFA has no replay value... It barely has any secrets while Mario has blue coins and a whopping 120 shines to collect. Not to mention huge awesome levels and a lot of replay value. I'd pick Mario over Fox any day.

[bobcat]

Haven't played SFA yet due to that stupid Lik Sang site getting sued for selling modified consoles :mad2:

but SMS is a worthy purchase if you own a GC. So fun!!

[Angrist]

Isn't it released on November 11th in Europe and perhaps also Aussi??

[Dyne]

I liked Star Fox Adventures much more than Mario Sunshine. Shoot me! Rare's last offering was much better. SMS was ok... I just didn't see what people were getting all excited about.

SFA>SMS.
SFA!=SMS.
SMS<SFA.

Heh?

[DarkDemonic726]

I got into Starfox Adventures more than i got into SMS.


Graphics:Starfox Adventures
Sound:Starfox Adventures
Challange:Super Mario Sunshine
Gameplay:Super Mario Sunshine
Fun Factor:Super Mario Sunshine
Length:Starfox Adventures

[CrOnO_LiNk]

Originally posted by DarkDemonic726
I got into Starfox Adventures more than i got into SMS.

Length:Starfox Adventures

Really? Star Fox Adventures took me 20 hours to beat easily while Mario Sunshine took me 30 hours. Also, I rushed Mario and took my time on Star Fox. I rushed Mario for a reason... That reason was because I got 3 new games the week I beat Mario. So I had to beat it fast to play SFA, KH, and AC.

[Jason1]

Im like 20% into SFA so far, and while its certinatley not ground-breaking gameplay wise, either was SMS. The thing that has impressed me most is the facial animations, particularly Fox's. Very impressive. I also like how you can actually see each blade of grass...this game is very pretty. Way too early for me to make judgement on if this game is better than SMS or not though.

[DeathsHand]

I only rented them (SMS a couple weeks ago, SFA just this past Saturday... so I still have it) but I like SFA better than SMS... SFA started off kinda bleck though... and it's not as good as I thought it'd be... but I still like... Both games, to me, seem like a bit of a dissapointment... although I didn't have the highest expectations for Mario in the first place... :-o

*hopes GTA:VC doesn't dissapoint me*

[Nocturnal_LIGHT]

ok thanks a lot u guys, i prefered LOZ:OOT rather than mario 64 so i'll go with SFA methinks, i'll get mario eventually.