NFL 2K3 Beats Madden 2003!!!!!!!!!!

[gekko]

IGN PS2

NFL 2K3 (http://ps2.ign.com/articles/367/367290p1.html) -- 9.2
Madden 2003 (http://ps2.ign.com/articles/367/367202p1.html) -- 9.1

IGN Xbox

NFL 2K3 (http://xbox.ign.com/articles/367/367317p1.html) -- 9.1
Madden 2003 (http://xbox.ign.com/articles/367/367194p1.html) -- 8.8
NFL Fever 2003 (http://xbox.ign.com/articles/366/366681p1.html) -- 7.7

IGN Cube

NFL 2K3 (http://cube.ign.com/articles/367/367401p1.html) -- 9.0
Madden 2003 (http://cube.ign.com/articles/367/367216p1.html) -- 8.8

NFL 2K3 wins on all platforms!

[Joeiss]

OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG.

Um..... They are both going to be great games, though. So I think I will test both of them out.

[Jonbo298]

:eek::WHOA: Wow! .1 point*faints*

[Perfect Stu]

luckily, I'm getting both :D

and did you realize that the reviews were written by two different people?

[gekko]

Originally posted by Perfect Stu
and did you realize that the reviews were written by two different people?

Doesn't matter. All that matters is I can laugh at Justin and say NFL 2K3 is better.

You people and your logic.

[gekko]

Scores added for Cube and Xbox.

[Joeiss]

Woah.... Beats Madden on all platforms... Should've anyways, lol. It is the same game! Except for online play on PS2....

[gekko]

Originally posted by Joeiss
Woah.... Beats Madden on all platforms... Should've anyways, lol. It is the same game! Except for online play on PS2....

Not always. Sometimes ports just really, really suck.

[Tombor]

Yeah a really big victory. Whopping 2-3 tenths of a point. :rolleyes:

Still though I'm curious about it. What's with Fever getting only a 7.7 though? Its fast and plays like Tecmo Super Bowl. Plus the hidden teams all look like they could've been XFL franchises and they all have their own unique stadiums with PA sounds relative to the team.

I do like Sega Sports anything alot, so once it comes out that'll probably be the one for me. Still 9.2 to 9.1? Not much of a victory....

[Perfect Stu]

the PS2 versions got the best scores :D

[gekko]

In addition, you'll probably be asking yourself how this game stacks up to Madden this year. There is but one thing to say: different reviewers, different reviews. I haven't played this year's Madden, yet. As for the other scores, I personally would have placed 2K2 firmly in the 8.4 range, and last year's Madden slightly higher at 8.6. By those standards, 9.2 is not only a great achievement for SEGA and VC, but a pretty darn good score. End of discussion.

That's from the NFL 2K3 reviewer.

[TheGame]

Lets just wait for the Nintendo power scores :rolleyes:

I think NFL 2k3 deserves a higher score ( :eek: )

Based off of improvements over last year, NFL 2k3 offered a better product... Madden has reached perfection in my book, so making improvements from year to year becomes hard. NFL 2k2 had more room to improve, and the potiential to do it.

What can Madden add? Madden has every feature of NFL 2k and more on top of that. Sega just simply has to rip off Madden (again) and new features will look that much better. Like an updated franchise mode. :rolleyes:

Madden looks to innovation, and innovation at this point is hard to find... so nextt thing you know, they will just be stuck changing to controll layout... wait, they already did that.

NFL 2k looks to Madden, learning how to build a better franchise mode and add more AI options.

I still personally like Madden more...haven't played NFL 2k yet... they both seem to be having thier best year ever.

My Champ is NCAA 2003.... I'm in my fifth season, on top of a full time job, I don't even see how I did it.

[Jonbo298]

The only thing Madden has left to perfect on is its Online Mode. 2 players only?!:Puke: There's always next year:unsure:

[Joeiss]

Originally posted by TheGame
Lets just wait for the Nintendo power scores :rolleyes:


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

:rofl:

Damn that's funny. And to think I used to buy videogames because of their scores. :(



Originally posted by Jonbo298
The only thing Madden has left to perfect on is its Online Mode. 2 players only?!:Puke: There's always next year:unsure:

I really wouldn't want it to be more than two players. I think it will be perfect the way it is. I mean, would you want somebody messing up a throw or a catch for you? Football is a team game, but when you play it as a videogame, one person should control it all.

[Perfect Stu]

Football video games should only be played with 2 players...

[TheGame]

Hmm... 2 player online isn't much of a flaw...

It's not like NFL 2k players go online with more than one player anyway...