Mafia Round 8 – War of Attrition

[Bond]

http://www.guidedbyyoda.com/images/yoda-400x300.jpg

Day Nine

No time for a narrative, sorry.

---

The Dead

The Germanator – Yoda (Villager) – Killed by the Mafia
Nighthawk – Emperor Palpatine (Villager) – Killed by the vote

Previously Dead

Vampyr – Qui-Gon Jinn (Villager) – Killed by the Mafia
tornadothrasher – Jabba the Hut t(Mafia) – Killed by the vote in round six
jeepnut – Padme Amidala (Villager) – Killed by the Mafia in round five
Swan – R2-D2 (Villager) – Killed by the vote in round five
Dylflon – Chewbacca (Seer) – Killed by the Mafia in round four
thatmariolover – Obi-Wan Kenobi (Villager) – Killed by the vote in round four
Fyacin - C-3PO (Vigilante) - Killed by the Mafia in round three
BreakABone - Admiral Ackbar (Mafia) - Killed by the vote in round three
Ric - Darth Vader (Villager) - Killed by the Vigilante in round two
Darmani - Darth Maul (Villager) - Killed by the Mafia in round two
Combine - Jango Fett (Mafia) - Killed by the vote in round two
Typhoid – Luke Skywalker (Guardian) – Killed by the Mafia in round one
Manasecret – Lando Calrissian (Villager) – Killed by the vote in round one


Player / Character List

1. Teuthida - Boba Fett
2. Bube - Princess Leia Organa
3. Angrist - Han Solo
4. BlueFire - General Grievous


This round will end tomorrow, Sunday June 21st, at 9:00 pm ET / 8:00 pm CT / 6:00 pm PT.

Make sure to get at least two posts in and your vote.

[Teuthida]

Fudge.

[Teuthida]

!vote Bube

Should have done this a long time ago. He didn't vote last round and the only one still left who Fyacin revealed he was the vigilante to.

I really hope I'm not wrong again.

[Angrist]

Wow, I didn't expect that to be honest!

Bube or BlueFire....

I just realized, this is the deciding round. If we kill off an innocent, the odds will be 1 to 1. The mafia will win.

So Bube and BlueFire, try and convince me.

[BlueFire]

Wow, I didn't expect that to be honest!

Bube or BlueFire....

I just realized, this is the deciding round. If we kill off an innocent, the odds will be 1 to 1. The mafia will win.

So Bube and BlueFire, try and convince me.

That's very presumptuous of you, Angrist. I don't know how many times I've had to defend myself already, but perhaps you should defend yourself.. because you're the first candidate for my vote.

[Angrist]

Let's start by telling why I'm the first candidate for your vote. I'd like to know.

And of course I don't want to vote for you if you're innocent. I want to win and I'm not going to waste my vote.

[Angrist]

Here I go again, spending too much time on this game.

BlueFire versus Bube

Round 1:
Both don’t post much (Bube 1, BF 2).
Nighthawk ‘has a feeling Bube is evil’.

Round 2:
BlueFire voted for the innocent Darmani. He is the first to do so. Darmani got killed off by the mafia this round.
Bube vividly defended Dylfon. Bube brings suspicion to Combine, because the latter randomly voted. Combine got voted off and turned out to be mafia.
BlueFire agrees with Bube that Combine is suspicious, but he never votes for him. Instead he votes for BaB, but he wasn’t even close to being voted off. Decoy?

Round 3:
Bube was the 2nd to vote for BaB. Later retracts his vote and goes for Swan.
BlueFire starts voting for Jeepnut when BaB is accused. He later retracts. Even though he was suspicious of BaB in round 2, he never votes for him again. In the end he votes for Angrist. If he hadn't retracted his vote for Jeepnut, he might have saved BaB.
When I posted that I found BF suspicious, he returned the favor.

Round 4:
Bube announces that he knows Fyacin told at least him, Jeepnut and Germy he was the vigilante. Concerned comment, or decoy??
Bube votes for BlueFire.
In response, BF raises suspicion of Bube.
Bube responds to that.
BlueFire says “It seems like you guys have signed thatmariolover's death warrant.” He also signs it and votes TML.
Nighthawk votes for Bube.

Will add the summary of the other rounds in a few hours.

All in all, Bluefire posted 28 times, Bube 19. In general I got the impression that Bube had interesting theories (offense and defense), while BlueFire only theorized when he was under suspicion himself.

Agh, I don't know. I'll finish it and read my own summary again. It seems like they both helped killing the mafia, at times.
Makes me want to vote for a 3rd party. :D You don't figure Dylflon would lie about Teuthida, do you?

[BlueFire]

Allow me to finish for you, Angrist:

Round 5
Bube votes for me, you vote for me and I vote for tornadothrasher. Swan and jeepnut are killed.

Round 6
I vote for tornadothrasher, you vote for tornadothrasher, Bube votes for tornadothrasher. Vampyr and tornadothrasher are killed.

Round 7
You vote Nighthawk, I vote Nighthawk, retract my vote and then vote for you. Bube doesn't vote. Nighthawk and Germanator die.

And now here we are, in the final round. I think I'm going to retract the allegation I made against you, Angrist.. because you have a record of voting for the mafia.. I guess that makes you trustworthy? Argh.. I don't know aijlfjalfjasijagif

Teuthida does make a good point. Bube is the last of the trio who knew of Fyacin being the vigilante.

I have to make a decision before leaving for Father's Day stuff.. but I don't want to.. haha

EDIT: it really sucks that the final round is on Father's Day.

[Angrist]

Where is Bube when you need him?

[BlueFire]

OK, I'm sorry. I have to go and I don't know if I'll be back in time for the end of the round. I'm siding with Teuthida on this.

!vote Bube

[Angrist]

This is going to get interesting.

Anyway, you summarized pretty much everything, but here's what I found:

Round 5:
Bube votes for BlueFire.
Angrist votes for BlueFire.
Nighthawk votes for BlueFire.
BlueFire votes for tornadothrasher.

Round 6:
BlueFire and tornadothrasher vote for each other. Diversion?
Bube votes for tornadothrasher. Diversion?

Round 7:
BlueFire votes for Nighthawk, changes it to Angrist.
Nighthawk votes for BF.
Bube misses his vote.

[Angrist]

Aargh I'm going crazy here. I've been counting 'good calls' and 'bad calls' in the summary I posted.

A lot of the actions can be understood in multiple ways. Both of them made decisive good calls. One of them has to be a decoy.

But I do count a lot more bad calls for BF. And one more good call for Bube.

It's tricky. They both could be mafia, we can't be sure. It depends on how smart they've played it. Bube would have had to have played it smarter than BlueFire.

!Vote BlueFire

It sucks that Bube and Teuthida aren't online yet. I hate doing this alone...

Vote Count Dooku:
Bube - 2
BlueFire - 1

[Bube]

Well yes, I'm back, and sorry for the last round. I was traveling, then fell asleep after I came home. I remembered that I hadn't posted this morning..

I know I'm under suspicion about the Fyacin thing. But there is the other possiblity that someone else knew he was the vigilante. But I had seriously suspected Germy. Too bad this now puts me on the radar. I can't say anything about this to defend myself, other than the fact that I was the one who brought this out..

However, I've always had that suspicion for BlueFire, and right now, there's just no other option than to vote for him. Both because of that nagging suspicion, and because I have to save myself, or at least take it to the coin toss .. :D

!vote BlueFire

[BlueFire]

I'm still not feeling very comfortable with the fact that Angrist has suddenly become one of the innocent ones, when we know that Teuthida is the only confirmed innocent one.. and yet, Angrist suddenly is free of suspicion. If this is indeed part of some plan you've devised, Angrist, then you are indeed smart.

!retract Bube

I gotta think about this some more.

EDIT: Well, 2 votes on me, eh? Now, I'm voting to save my own hide rather than an attempt to find the true mafioso.

!vote Bube

:lolz:

COUNT:
Bube- 2
Bluefire- 2

..that is, unless Teuthida changes his mind. :/

[Angrist]

EDIT: Well, 2 votes on me, eh? Now, I'm voting to save my own hide rather than an attempt to find the true mafioso.Not much use in saving our own hides here, is there? After this round either the last mafioso is dead, or the mafia wins the game.

It's comments like those that make me suspect you most. But I tried not to base my vote on that, because some people are just bad at posting (look at Germy).

If nobody changes a vote, the end of the game will be decided by a coin toss. A 50% chance for both parties...

[Angrist]

Let's make things a bit more interesting again. I was getting ready for bed, and while brushing my teeth I considered my vote. I suddenly realized something.

If you're the last mafioso, you don't care who gets voted off, as long as it's not you.

But what happens here? BlueFire defends himself and tries to attack me. Even though Bube has more votes than me, he still suspects me most. You'd expect him to give up on that by now, if he were part of the mafia. It wouldn't matter, he should just try to kill off Bube.
Now Bube, he comes in here, apolagizes for yesterday as if it's nothing. Defends himself a bit. And does the obvious thing. He votes for BlueFire, his vote-rival. No discussions, no last-round theories. He just wants somebody dead.

So that is why....

!retract BlueFire

!vote Bube

Insert epic statement here.

[Bond]

Still plenty of time before the round ends to change votes, etc.

Just so everyone knows, I will close this thread at the designated time, and then make a post-game thread (as the game is going to end one way or another) where all players are welcome to post.