Gamespot reviewer fired over bad review?

[Bond]

Kotaku received an anonymous tip yesterday about long time GameSpot reviewer Jeff Gerstmann being fired because of a low score he gave to Kane & Lynch: Dead Men. The more interesting and disturbing part is that GameSpot was apparently under pressure from Eidos Interactive, the publisher of the game.

GameSpot has been littered with Kane & Lynch ads recently and Eidos threatened to pull the plug, meaning a loss of revenue for CNET-owned GameSpot. Despite the Kotaku tipster specifying that it wasn’t necessarily the low score of 6 out of 10 but the ‘tone’ of the review that got the man fired, the day when advertisers will be able to get reviewers fired and set the tone of reviews by waving a stack of cash at your face is a sad day indeed.

Surprisingly, there are no Kane & Lynch ads on GameSpot at the time of writing, instead the site is displaying ads for Ubisoft’s Assassin’s Creed. Did Eidos pull the advertising anyway or is GameSpot trying to save face ? (Update below)

Shacknews has also confidently confirmed from their end that Gerstmann has indeed been fired from his position (update below). And former GameSpot editor and current MP3.com - also CNET-owned - employee Tim Tracy has posted what seems to be a farewell notice on his GameSpot blog. It’s unknown if it’s related to the Gerstmann axing.

My gut tells me this isn’t the last we’ve heard of this, so we’ll keep you updated when new information surfaces. But with this fiasco going on, makes you wonder how the industry will receive Kane & Lynch 2, which is already in production. Because when (and if) it releases, references to this incident will no doubt be made.

Update: Jeff Gerstmann has since confirmed himself that he has indeed been let go. He’s “not really able to comment on the specifics” but is “looking forward to getting back out there and figuring out what’s next.” In the meanwhile huge forum topics have grown in the GameSpot forums, especially this one with over 4800 posts. The official Eidos forums got a similar treatment but after shutting it down for a while, the admins are now locking any thread discussing this topic at first sight, calling it a rumor and saying “there will be no further discussion.”

Penny Arcade writes that they’re being told the advertisements that Eidos was displaying on GameSpot were worth hundreds of thousands of dollars and that they’ve now pulled hundreds of thousands worth of future advertising from the site.

Source: ShoutWire (http://www.shoutwire.com/viewstory/118470/GameSpot_Reviewer_Fired_Over_Bad_Review)

Thoughts?

Here's the video review in question if anyone is curious:

<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/aBD0cUeeEQc&rel=1&border=0"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/aBD0cUeeEQc&rel=1&border=0" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

[manasecret]

http://www.penny-arcade.com/images/2007/20071129.jpg


What can I say. Yeah if true the whole thing is shite.

[Professor S]

The 10 point scale is a result of publisher and industry influence. Ever wonder why we consider a review of 7 out of 10 bad? Because the industry could not tolerate ratings of 2-3 out of 10. So the real scale is a 6 or 7 to 10 scale, which is really just an adjusted 1 to 4 stars. Its an attempt to alter perception.

In the end, the game reviewing journalists are beholden to the industry not only to provide the product for review ahead of release, but also to ASVERTISE and pay for the sites to actually exist and their employees to get paid.

Its best not to bite the hand that feeds.

[Dyne]

..Dude, that happened like over a week ago. There's been a million repercussions since.

Someone has to start reading Kotaku. :)

[Professor S]

..Dude, that happened like over a week ago. There's been a million repercussions since.

Someone has to start reading Kotaku. :)

Ah yes, we operate on the internet, where a week is a lifetime.

Can you link what you mention on Kotaku?

[Swan]

Yeah, I read about that last week on Penny Arcade:p

[Bond]

..Dude, that happened like over a week ago. There's been a million repercussions since.

Someone has to start reading Kotaku. :)
I know.

But I just got around to posting it. :)

[TheGame]

Haha, I like that review. He completly made the game sound like crap with no hope. I'm shocked it even got a 6. Also, "Ugly" is a strong word, and he made tha the centerpiece of his review. I bet the developers of that game love that dude :P

[GameMaster]

Where to begin?

Eidos and Gamespot's reputations are both fucked.

Edios is corrupt scum. Gamespot is a cashwhore.

The morale of the entire editing team at Gamespot is shot and many have already suggested they're thinking about leaving.

The majority of Gamespot's visitors and forum posters have left indefinitely. Or at least until Gertsmann is given justice.

Many gamers are now boycotting Eidos.

To hell with both of them.

[KillerGremlin]

this happened like an internet year ago, there is already talk about gamespot writers leaving now

check out destructoid now: http://www.cashwh0re.com/

[Angrist]

Many gamers are now boycotting Eidos.But most people did that already anyway.

The morale of the entire editing team at Gamespot is shot and many have already suggested they're thinking about leaving.They suggested that they were thinking about leaving? We're gonna need something better than that.